Why You Are Not A Service Provider

blogproblems

This post was inspired from a conversation I had with Chris Brogan at BlogWorld Expo 2009. Chris is so damn productive, I have given him a nickname. Henceforth, he is “The Broganator,” but that is beside the point.

We were standing around in a little circle with a couple other people after a session Chris had paneled, talking about business. Any time we dig a little deeper into our blogs to make them more successful, we’re reminded they have a business end. We’re reminded which end is dog, which end is tail, and which end is supposed to be wagging the other (most people have it exactly backwards in practice).

One Very Important Thing

In order to be successful in business, and market that business successfully via blogging, you have to know one Very Important Thing. You have to know what problem you’re solving. There’s more to it than just that, but let’s leave it at that for now, as an introductory idea.

Most businesses don’t take a problem-solving approach. They take a service-provider approach. How many people you ask say, “I provide design services,” or “I provide consulting services?” Even if the word services doesn’t make an appearance, it’s often assumed.

But when our prospective clients reach a point where they need our services, what has happened in their lives? Often, they’ve suffered a problem that needs fixing. They may not even know what service to search for. All they know is they have a problem. If my stomach hurts, and I want to search online for relief, I’m not going to type “irritable bowel syndrome” into the Google search box, because I don’t know that’s what I have. What do you think I’m going to type in?

Framing the Problem

If you guessed, “stomach pain” or similar, high five yourself (or on second thought, don’t, because to other people that just looks like a weird clap and you’ll get funny looks). Now, if we’re selling a product that relieved stomach pain, our marketing objectives for blog content are clear.

But what if we sell services? Our potential clients still suffer from pain, but it’s more of a situational, logistical, or anxiety-based kind of pain. Our clients don’t necessarily want services. They didn’t wake up today wondering, “Gee, where I can I get me some good career coaching services?” They woke up saying, “Damn, not another Monday! I hate this job! How can I get out of this without putting my family’s well-being in danger?”

They want their problem to go away—preferably with as little involvement as possible on their part.

Google’s Big Mistake

Let me pick on a giant company as an illustration: Google.  Google has created several services which are languishing or riddled with problems based around large-scale user annotation of the web. Google SearchWiki is not even used by people. Google Knol is a ghost town. And Google SideWiki is turning into a huge, sad joke. Why does Google fail so badly with these services?

Because they’re trying to solve a problem nobody has.

When I said that in our after-session conversation at BlogWorld, Brogan immediately lit up and he said he really liked that phrase (Chris: steal it, use it). That’s the connection between BlogWorld and this post.

Think about your own business, your own blog. Are you having difficulty attracting qualified traffic that converts? Could be you’re not solving anyone’s problem.

“But wait a minute,” I hear you say (yes, I really heard that), “I do solve a particular problem! I solve ___________.” That’s good if you know that. But if your business blog marketing still isn’t pulling like you want, there’s a likely reason for that. It’s because even though you know what problem you’re solving for your clients, your blog isn’t doing a good job of communicating that. Go back and look at your posts from the fresh perspective of a complete stranger: do you see more than one post where the problem you solve is clearly stated in headlines and post content? Yes, you have to be that blatant, that direct about it.

Your First Step

Your first step in the right direction is to forget about labeling yourself as a service provider, and begin calling yourself a problem solver. And yeah, the observant among you will notice I’m not doing that here on my own blog. I’m sharing this with you before I implement it myself (because it’s that important). I’ve been telling this to my blog consulting clients and blog coaching groupsas well, for months (they have a head start on you, and they also have my specific guidance for their individual businesses and blogs).

We’re not service-providers. We’re problem-solvers. But, more than that, we want to be sure we’re solving the problem our clients believe they have. Let’s make sure we’re not making the same mistake as Google. Don’t try to solve a problem no one has. You and I don’t have Google’s vast resources to create and then discard such costly projects.

By the way, as I hinted at above, there is something beyond problem solving. That’ll be the next post. Stay tuned.

Your Thoughts

Have you been thinking of yourself as a service provider? If you had to write down what problem you solve, what would that look like? Leave a comment below and let me know. Help each other refine your “problem statements.”

  • http://willowsmarsh.com Karen Masullo

    I’m reading this because your title hits a passion of mine, which proves your thesis.

    As a career transition and outplacement company, this is exactly how we counsel candidates and corporate clients.

    Reminds me of the adage “Marketing is telling, selling is listening.”

    I LOVE the phrase of trying to solve a problem nobody has.

    Will use this this weekend at BarcampCHS. Thank you!

    @OPCGal

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      Karen, that’s awesome! Glad it struck a chord with you. Interesting that this has application to what you do, because it shows no matter what, we really are all in business for ourselves.

  • http://www.kaplancopy.com/blog Jodi Kaplan

    I like to call it having a secret identity. It’s the difference between what you appear to be selling, and what you’re actually selling. For example, Disney isn’t in the theme park business, it’s in the happiness business.

    A few months ago, I stumbled across a really bad case of solving a problem nobody has. It was a bra dryer. It came in one size (?!) and somehow you strap the thing inside and…. who knows. Now, a speedy sweater dryer or a speedy jeans dryer – would actually be useful, but this?

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      Ooh! Secret identity! I like that!

  • http://clericaladvantage.com Tina Marie Hilton

    Is it a coincidence that you wrote this post just when I’m realizing that I’m ready to refocus my business blogsite due to some changes and growth taking place in my business?
    It really just makes sense that people aren’t looking for services but rather answers to their problems.
    I immediately wrote down a short list of problems I can solve.
    Thank for sharing this valuable advice with us…for free.

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      Tina, thanks! There are limits to free advice, and not because I’m stingy with my knowledge or experience, but because it can never be specific to each reader’s situation. That’s why I do one-on-one and group consulting/coaching. Often, people need help with this kind of high level thinking, somebody to help them clarify for themselves and push through self-imposed mental/emotional barriers. If you feel like you can’t “get past yourself,” it’s time to call for reinforcements. :)

  • http://mikestankavich.com Mike Stankavich

    Michael, I agree with your premise 100%. By focusing on problems that you can solve, you are emphasizing benefits, whereas if you focus on services offered, you are focusing on features. I will absolutely keep this in mind as I expand my website/blog.

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      Mike, that is a great observation matching services with features and problem-solving with benefits! Thanks for adding to this discussion!

  • http://www.MarketingBeyondAdvertising.com/blog/ Tom Wanek

    Exactly. So many business owners are answering a question no one is asking. It’s critical that marketers first accurately identify the felt need of the customer that they are willing and able to meet.

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      Tom, exactly. Otherwise, with a blog, you’re just writing to wrong people!

  • http://www.handsontheheartland.com Lenexa

    Taking a problem solving angle with the headline and following through to solve a likely customer issue makes a lot of sense.

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      I like the idea of “following through” from headline to article text. Excellent!

  • http://IRREVERENTreluctantFUTURIST.com the_IRF

    Hurray for Michael,

    Now, if I could just get people to use me and take advantage of having their own personal REAL energy on their side with what they choose to do, then i would actually be making a difference in people’s lives and they would learn how to listen to their voice-within.
    The NEW STORY is coming fast and hard. You think the world is ridding off the rails now, just wait. There is a reason why this is happening; when you finally get driven into the voice-within foxhole, you will get it why stuff has happened as it has.
    Thanks for the Truth, Michael,
    @the_IRF

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      IRF, you may have to work at explaining things in a way people understand. You need to use their terminology before you can begin educating them on your terminology.

  • Warren Denley

    Thanks for the great distinction – explains why our business has felt like it has been drifting for the last few years. We have changed focus a few times over that period, but never really attracted the right clients.
    Funny thing is – I have always enjoyed the problem solving aspect of what I do the most, but for some reason continue to market myself as a service provider. Well, that is all changing now!

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      Warren, that sounds like the beginning of a great plan!

  • http://www.bloginterface.net BlogInterface.net

    In my posts, I tend to make clear the problem-solution “thing”: I introduce the problem, then give the solution for this problem. I always give my best to answer how to solve a problem. The best advices always come from your own experiences.

    Another example is choosing a blog niche. Even if you think that your idea about a niche is remarkable, you fail because the topic you are writing about solves nobody’s problem. How to solve a problem when it even doesn’t exist? The result is that nobody reads your blog.

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      Good point about choosing a niche for a blog. People want to succeed doing what they love, but you still have to take into account how what you love helps others.

  • http://www.howshereallydoesit.com Koren Motekaitis

    Michael,

    Thanks got my brain thinking about how I am going to apply this to my business. I love solving problems. That is what I do well, now I need to work on conveying that online. So glad I decided to take your group blog coaching program!

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      Thanks, Koren, I’m so glad to have you in the program! Have fun applying this to your business, and let me know what happens.

  • http://IRREVERENTreluctantFUTURIST.com the_IRF

    Yes, Michael, you are so very correct about explaining things in a way people understand. This I have attempted to do, extensively, in my blog pages and posts [http://eductivefuturegroup.com/]and even on my website.
    If any of our class would graciously care to take the time to read my work, and tell me what is missing for them to grasp what I am trying to get across, I would be most appreciative. For those in our group who are of the female persuasion, i would point them to: http://eductivefuturegroup.com/?page_id=71
    I fully get it about information that goes counter to, or seems to stand contrary to, what most people have adopted as their understanding.
    Using peoples’ present terminology for information or concepts that do not exist in their lexicon is difficult. Were the blog to be read, then the needed background and comprehension would be obtained.
    Interestingly enough, my readership seems to be gaining by leaps and bounds in Russia, and they have to read an automated translation. They get it, instinctively, but that is because of their natural cultural disposition. I think they sense the transition in a way that our cultural entrainment prohibits. It is natural for their culture to be mystic or to hear the voice-within.
    I know that when I studied there, briefly, in 1973 the KGB was hugely interested in me because, as I was told, they could understand my energy signature. Remember it was about at that time they were doing a lot of research on remote viewing, psychic seeing, and all things mystic. Their instrumentation and “readers” got it that my “signature” was off the charts. They have watched me sense. They, the Pentagon, and The Oval Office have, until now, been the only ones who knew of my skill-set, and then, only occasionally, was i permitted to give any of them ‘heads-up’ information on a What is Needed basis.
    So, in a nutshell, no one will read my stuff, until it is What is Needed. I know this, but still I bitch and complain.
    Our culture trains us to always ask our voice-within if “it”, whatever we are interested in, will sell. This is not a problem, except, in our culture, we generally refuse to hear when the information is trying to tell us that we should be interested in a different “market”, or a different “product”, or worst of all, that we should move away from the “selling” orient that we are anchored to as our identity or as our meaning in life and do something different to obtain real balance in stead of the false-balance rewards of the “sell”.
    Still, Michael, you deserve much thanks for the interest and genuine effort to help me. It is much appreciated.
    Respectfully,
    @the_IRF

  • http://promptwebdesign.com Vancouver Web Design

    Hard to argue with this. I just came from a seminar that framed this approach in a different way. The facilitator suggested using elevator pitches such as: “I help companies like MTV to gain access to large number of visitors” instead of “I do SEO”. The first option assumes the point of view of the customer and the second the POV of the provider.

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      Vancouver, that’s a great point. Thanks for your comment!

    • http://www.bloginterface.net BlogInterface.net

      @Vancouver Web Design: very deep words. And something else to add: you say to your customers that you help MTV. Said that, your customers acknowledge two things: first, that your are working for MTV (what is obvious), and second, that by working for MTV you are a professional. That changes everything.

  • http://hunternuttall.com Hunter Nuttall

    “They’re trying to solve a problem nobody has.”

    This reminds me of Lisa Simpson. Flanders called her “Springfield’s answer to a question no one asked.”

    As such, while she has a ton of potential, she’s very unappreciated, much like those Google services.

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      Yeah, but nobody would say “get rid of Lisa Simpson.”

  • http://b6s.net/ Anne at B6S.net

    I agree with your basic notion there. That said, I also think there can be other objectives to running a blog, and these can still, albeit indirectly, contribute towards your overall business success. Blogs are a great tool for branding, especially when combined with social media marketing.

    • http://remarkablogger.com Michael Martine

      Anne, to my way of thinking, branding is a side effect of the reader-prospect experience, not a main goal. Branding does not put money in the bank and it isn’t anything anyone cares about because it doesn’t help them do anything.

  • Pingback: Weekly Brief: Week Ending 11/7/2009 | The Inspired Solo

  • http://mktgbytes.wordpress.com/ Tim Nicholas

    I kept this post and re-read it today as I prepare for a business networking event tomorrow, where I need to have well-prepared 'pitch' message ready to connect with lots of prospects. Your article has helped me enormously to fine-tune how I will talk about my business offering in just 30 seconds! Thanks Michael.

  • remarkablogger

    Tim, you're welcome. I know you'll be great!

  • remarkablogger

    Tim, you're welcome. I know you'll be great!

  • http://mktgbytes.wordpress.com/ Tim Nicholas

    I kept this post and re-read it today as I prepare for a business networking event tomorrow, where I need to have well-prepared 'pitch' message ready to connect with lots of prospects. Your article has helped me enormously to fine-tune how I will talk about my business offering in just 30 seconds! Thanks Michael.

    • remarkablogger

      Tim, you're welcome. I know you'll be great!

Headway ad
Headway